Fish Creek Market

"Door County's Finest Deli, Sub Sandwiches, and Gourmet Foods available at Fish Creek Market in
Fish Creek, Wisconsin."

Home Custom Made Sandwiches Specials Contact Us Reviews

Phone: 920-868-3351


Mon. - Fri.: 8 am - 8 pm
Saturday: 9 am - 6 pm
Sunday: 9 am - 5 pm

Fish Creek Market

Fish Creek Market is a family owned and operated grocery and specialty food store located in the heart of Door County, Wisconsin. Built in 1895, it remains one of the oldest continuously operating independent grocery stores in the country and continues to be a focal point of the community. 

No trip to Door Country would be complete without visiting the Fish Creek Market. If you stop in during the morning, you’ll be greeted with the smell of freshly brewed coffee just-baked muffins, scones, and croissants. Stop by for lunch and our baked-daily baguettes and rolls grab your sense of smell. We’re proud to make many of our deli and bakery items from scratch, right in our own kitchen. We also offer an extensive selection of wine and beer, including many different craft labels from throughout Wisconsin.

  • Custom Made Sandwiches, made famous by Gary and Ann Norz
  • Specialty Gourmet Foods
  • Delicatessen featuring homemade salads, and an array of fresh-sliced meats and cheeses
  • Fine wines from around the world
  • Large selection of imported, domestic, microbrewed, and Door County beers
  • Fresh produce department, including organic offerings
  • Wide selection of cheese, including many from right here in Wisconsin 
  • Candy and confections for your sweet tooth
  • Local brand “Death's Door” Gin, Vodka, and Whiskey
  • Large selection of liquor to help you kick back
  • Marinades to use when you fire up the grill
  • Baking products if you want to create your own masterpiece
  • Fresh bakery made daily
  • Sauces and dressings for every occasion
  • Products made right here in Door County
  • Gourmet crackers and nuts
  • Snacks and munchies like
  • Door County Coffee and Tea
  • Grilling accessories to help make your grilling experience easy as well as spices and seasonings
  • Picnic supplies such as paper plates, plastic cups, etc.
  • Bathroom items and other cosmetic must-haves
  • Laundry supplies
  • First aid supplies and medicine to help you heal up
  • Pet food for man’s best friend (and cats…)


Door County Products

We are extremely proud to be able to offer a selection of products that are produced right here in Door County, including:

  • Island Orchard Ciders
  • Door Peninsula Wines
  • Renard’s cheeses
  • Orchard Country Wines
  • Seaquist Canning Co. canned jams and fruits
  • Simon Creek Wines


4164 Main St.- The Building

The building that currently houses the Fish Creek Market has an extensive history, dating back to 1895 when it was first constructed as the Hill General Store. When it opened, it was the second general store in the community, with a third opening just a few years later. Originally, the store house a large wood stove in the middle of the store, to prevent products freezing during the cold winter months. The upstairs level (now Mr. Helsinki’s Restaurant and Wine Bar) was used as the community gathering place, hosting everything from sock-hops to basketball games. The building underwent and extensive renovation in 2000 and the result is a stunning mix of the old and new.


The Owners

The current owners are the brother-sister duo of John Seiberlich and Anne Alberts. They also own Top Shelf Café and Gourmet, located roughly 15 minutes north of Fish Creek Market in Sister Bay. John has an extensive knowledge of wine and cheese and hand-picks each bottle and block we bring into the Market. Anne is an expert chef and is responsible for many of our deli items, of course made from scratch. She has also been a fixture in the community, serving as a paramedic for many years as well as one of the high school’s girls’ sports coaches. John’s son, Bryan, is the General Manager of the Market and is always working to ensure your visit to Fish Creek Market is a memorable one.

We look forward to serving you!

Fish Creek Market Features:

  • Legendary Custom Made Sandwiches

  • Specialty Gourmet Foods

  • Delicatessen Featuring Great Homemade Soups & Salads

  • Wines from Around the World as well as Local Door County Wines

  • Cherries and Apples in Season

  • Large Selection of Import, Domestic, Microbrew Beers, and Door County Beers

  • Fresh Produce Department

  • Local Door County Cheeses from Renard's Door County Cheese

  • Candy and Confections including gourmet chocolates

  • Local Death's Door Gin, Vodka, and Whiskey

  • Large selection of alcohol and liquor

  • Gourmet and Specialty Foods

  • Marinades

  • Baking Products like The Invisible Chef

  • Fresh Bakery Items including:

    • Breads

    • Cherry Pie

    • Pastries

  • Canned Foods Sauces and Dressings

  • Spices and Seasonings

  • Cheese and Gourmet Crackers

  • Snacks and Munchies like:

    • Cookies

    • Chips

  • Stonewall Kitchen and Elki products

  • Local Jams and Jellies

  •  Intelligentia coffee (Chicago) and Just Coffee (Madison)

  • Grilling accessories like Fire Starters and Charcoal

  • Laundry Detergent for your Laundry Needs

  • Catering and Party items such as Cups, Plates, Silverware and much more

  • Bathroom items

  • Health and Beauty Products such as Soap, Shampoo, etc.

  • Medicine like Aspirin, Cold Medicine and more

  • Pet Food for Dogs and Cats

No trip to Door County would be complete without trying our famous custom-made sandwiches – a true Fish Creek Market tradition. We also feature a wide selection of cheeses, salads, and fine Usinger meats. Great soups are also available including Jeanne’s award winning Black Bean Turkey Chili. Also check out our breads baked fresh each day.

Our variety of specialty foods continues to grow and change.
Jeanne is always on the lookout for new and unique items to compliment our existing selection. Following is a sample of products we carry:

  • Robert Rothchild
  • Stonewall Kitchen
  • Cherith Valley
  • Private Harvest
  • Great selection of domestic and import cheeses
  • Teas, including Revolution, Numi, and Republic of Tea

We offer a fine selection of our popular Fish Creek Market private label jams, jellies, cherry pie filling, and dressings. We also carry Door County Mustard, Door County Coffee, Jorns Maple Syrup, and more! Again, please visit our online store for a complete listing.

Come into the store and discover a wide range of high quality reasonably priced wines. We research all of our wines thoroughly and provide information of lesser known, but still sensational tasting varietals. We also feature an exceptional variety of local Door County wines.

During the months of May through October, we are a full service grocery store offering essential foods including fresh produce and meats. In the off-season, while our selection of grocery items is somewhat limited, it’s a great time to discover our other products.

In 2000 our building went through a major restoration providing a fascinating blend of old and new styles of decor. The result is a truly unique shopping experience. Jeanne and Mike Hyde are committed to offering quality service and products as well as our legendary custom made sandwiches. We offer a wide variety of specialty foods, bakery, and wine. Be sure to stop in and discover for yourself why we have such a loyal following.







Home Custom Made Sandwiches Specials Contact Us Reviews

Page Summary: Fish Creek Market offers grocery store, deli, wines, coffee, market, fresh vegetables, beer, micro brews, liquor, gourmet and specialty foods in Door County, Fish Creek, Egg Harbor, Sister Bay, Ephraim, Baileys Harbor, Ellison Bay, Sturgeon Bay, Carlsville, Green Bay and surrounding Door County WI communities.

Best of Upper Midwest Directory

Share This Page    
© Copyright 2010, LLC   Powered by Page 1 SEO Design, LLC